I am utterly surprised at the
'shit storm' and number of comments that my post on circumcision generated. I never would have imagined it. Early on in my thought process we were going to have the Circ' done. After all, 'that's what's done.' Then I read some and backed off on the decision. I wrote the
previous post with a neutral position. This post will focus on comment reply/ discussions and my current train of thought.
More than one Commenter suggested some specific web sites:
There were also a couple of other web sites suggested:
I have also read the articles in
Mothering magazine. Though, it does seem that there is much more
anti-circumcision information available than
pro-circ'.
The
National Organization of Restoring Men tries to help men reconstruct it.
*?. ahh, ohh-kay* but it is an irreversible procedure. And I doubt it can work. You just can't restore natural nerve endings.
The statics seem to be all over the place. One thing I learned that was helpful was that the practice is on the decline in the US. The Mothering magazine published that worldwide only 30% have circum's. 2/3rds of which are Muslim. So, its really the Jews and Muslims that seem to drive a big part of it. Maybe fighting in the
Middle East would come to and end if all the men just showed each other their dicks?
The Penis Accords :)
There were pleas in the commenting, not to do it. "
Take your whole son home.."
There were many first hand experiences from both men and women. My favorite was from
Adam Smith, a 15 year old:
"honestly bro, I really wouldn't do it. I'm 15 and my parents had me "crimped ", watch the videos its pretty gross"
I did read somewhere that
Smegma does have some health benefit. Something about anit-
bacterial properties. An argument that kept coming up was that it should be my son's choice. I don't think this is solid since that as parents we need to make decisions for them all the time. This just happens to need a little extra thought.
I once had a gym teacher who told us that when he joined the Navy he had to get circed' before admittance. He and a few guys were there and after the 'procedure' they were all in the same room, And I guess that the nurse was real good looking, so the kept getting boners and making the new cut re-open. "OUCH!" Then they would take smelling salts or something to...ah, soften the rod.
The poll I posted is currently running about 69% No.
This is kind of like having my dogs tail docked, and interesting the hygiene issue is used for that procedure as well. Let me now 'cut to the chase', if you will, and end this shit.
After it all washes out I think the biggest factors in helping make a decision to keep the skin are:
The factors not to keep it are:
- looks for the ladies (well, some of them),
- locker room ridicule, and
- the UTI decrease.
I hope that this adds a real perspective to the debate on circumcision for any new dad's or mom's out there looking for guidance. It's not just statics. It's not just religious. It's not just appearance.